Does a Shower or a Tub Add More Value to a Home?

When homeowners embark on a bathroom remodel, one of the most common debates is whether to install a shower or a tub. Both options offer unique benefits, but when it comes to adding value to a home, the decision can significantly impact resale potential. So, which one is better? Let’s explore the pros and cons of tubs and showers, and how each can contribute to the overall value of your home.

The Importance of Bathroom Remodeling in Adding Home Value

Bathroom remodels consistently rank among the top home improvement projects that provide a solid return on investment (ROI). Whether you’re preparing to sell or simply want to increase your home’s market value, upgrading your bathroom can make a significant difference. According to real estate experts, even modest bathroom renovations can offer an ROI of 60% to 70%. That means homeowners can recoup a substantial portion of the renovation costs when they sell their property.

A key question homeowners face during a remodel is whether they should prioritize tubs or showers to maximize their investment. Each has its appeal, and the choice often depends on factors such as buyer demographics, personal preferences, and the home’s overall design.

The Benefits of Installing a Bathtub

Tubs have long been a staple in homes, offering a luxurious experience that appeals to a wide variety of buyers. Let’s explore some of the key reasons why tubs can be a valuable addition to a bathroom remodel.

Appeal to Families with Young Children

Families with young children often prefer homes that have bathtubs. Bath time is a daily routine for many families, and tubs provide a safe and convenient way for parents to bathe their children. If you’re planning a remodel in a family-oriented neighborhood, adding or maintaining a bathtub can increase your home’s attractiveness to potential buyers.

A Relaxing Retreat

Bathtubs are often associated with relaxation and luxury. A deep soaking tub, particularly one with jets or whirlpool features, creates a spa-like atmosphere that appeals to many homebuyers. For those who enjoy long, hot baths as a way to unwind, a tub can be a major selling point.

Adds a Sense of Luxury

When it comes to adding value with a bathroom remodel, luxury features are often a key factor. Freestanding tubs, clawfoot tubs, or modern soaking tubs can elevate the design of the bathroom and contribute to an upscale aesthetic. Homes in higher-end markets or areas where buyers expect luxury will often benefit from the presence of a high-quality bathtub.

Considerations for Future-Proofing

Another factor to consider is that many people associate bathtubs with long-term usability. Homebuyers looking for a “forever home” may value the presence of a tub, particularly as it provides an option for future bathing needs should physical limitations arise. Walk-in tubs, for example, are a great option for homeowners looking to age in place.

The Benefits of Installing a Shower

While tubs are a great option for certain buyers, showers have their own set of advantages, especially when space and convenience are priorities.

Space-Saving Solutions

In homes where square footage is limited, a shower is often the more practical option. Showers can take up significantly less space than a tub, allowing for more efficient use of the bathroom’s layout. This is especially important in smaller homes or urban areas where maximizing every square inch is crucial.

Faster and More Convenient

For many busy homeowners, showers are a more convenient option than tubs. Showers offer a quick and efficient way to start the day, which is appealing to those with hectic schedules. If your target buyers are young professionals or individuals who prioritize functionality, showers can add significant appeal to your bathroom remodel.

Walk-In Showers: A Modern Design Trend

Walk-in showers have become a popular choice in modern bathroom design. They offer a sleek, streamlined look that can give any bathroom an updated, contemporary feel. Adding a walk-in shower, especially one with frameless glass doors or multiple showerheads, can instantly enhance the luxury factor of the bathroom.

Accessibility and Aging in Place

As the population ages, many homebuyers are prioritizing accessibility in home design. Walk-in showers, especially those with barrier-free or curbless entries, are ideal for homeowners who want to age in place or who may have mobility issues. Adding a shower that accommodates accessibility needs can increase the value of your home, especially if you’re targeting older buyers or those with disabilities.

Combining Both: The Best of Both Worlds

One of the most popular trends in modern bathroom design is the inclusion of both a tub and a shower. This option offers the best of both worlds, allowing homeowners to enjoy the luxury of a bath and the convenience of a shower. For larger bathrooms, incorporating both can significantly enhance the overall value of the home, as it caters to a broader range of potential buyers.

Tub and Shower Combos

For homeowners who are limited on space but still want the option of both, a tub-shower combination is an excellent compromise. These units provide the convenience of a shower while maintaining the functionality of a bathtub, making them a practical choice for families, especially in smaller homes.

Separate Shower and Tub Layouts

In larger bathrooms, separating the shower and tub can create a more luxurious, spa-like feel. A freestanding tub paired with a large walk-in shower offers a sense of grandeur and relaxation that appeals to high-end buyers. This combination is often seen in luxury homes, where space is abundant, and buyers expect high-quality finishes and features.

Does a Shower or Tub Add More Value?

So, does a shower or a tub add more value to a home? The answer depends on your target market and the specific features of your home.

• Family-Oriented Buyers: If your home is in a neighborhood with families, a bathtub can be an essential selling point, as parents often need tubs for young children.
• Luxury Buyers: High-end buyers may expect both a tub and a shower, with a focus on luxury finishes and design. A separate soaking tub or a modern walk-in shower can add substantial value in this market.
• Urban Buyers or Small Spaces: In areas where space is limited, a well-designed shower can be a major selling point. Walk-in showers with modern features tend to appeal to younger, urban buyers who prioritize convenience and efficiency.
• Aging Buyers or Accessibility Needs: Showers, particularly walk-in or curbless designs, are a practical choice for buyers looking for long-term accessibility. If your home is in an area with an older population, this feature can significantly enhance the home’s appeal.

Final Thoughts on Adding Value with a Bathroom Remodel

When deciding between tubs or showers during a bathroom remodel, consider the preferences of your potential buyers and the overall style and function of your home. While both options have the potential to add value, the best choice ultimately depends on who will be buying your home in the future.

By understanding the advantages of each, you can make an informed decision that maximizes your return on investment, enhancing your home’s appeal and boosting its market value.

Whether you choose a tub, a shower, or a combination of both, it’s clear that adding value with a bathroom remodel is a smart move for homeowners looking to improve both the functionality and aesthetics of their property.

Need a Remodeling Contractor in Santa Fe, NM?

Welcome to Apple Construction LLC.! Apple Construction LLC. has been in business since 2015 and has been serving Santa Fe, New Mexico and surrounding areas ever since. We specialize in new construction, remodels, additions, design consultations and planning, and so much more! At Apple Construction, LLC., we pride ourselves on our customer service and honesty. We provide each of our clients with quality work and dependability. Apple Construction LLC. has been locally owned and operated for the past 30 years and counting. We have local ties with the Chamber of Commerce and we are also proud members of the Better Business Bureau. Give us a call today and we’ll get started on your dream home!

Categorised in: Bathrooms